CIRCULAR FASHION
CIRCULAR ECONOMY AND RENTAL FASHION SERVICE =
CIRCULAR FASHION – A SUSTAINABLE ALTERNATIVE TO THE FASHION INDUSTRY OR…?
By Anna Vejen Durán
I bet you have heard about the word sustainability when it comes to fashion– am I right?
Nowadays we seem to hear and read the word sustainability in political debates, in advertisements, in articles and posts on social media. I first consciously noticed the word when the United Nations published “17 Sustainable Development Goals – also called the SDG goals in 2016. Regarding the fashion industry, the word sustainability has also made its mark, but this is not new. What is (relatively) new, is how some fashion brands use circular economy, also called circular fashion, as a more sustainable approach towards consuming- and producing fashion in the industry. However, it is interesting to examine the pros and cons of this circular approach, since one could question the sustainable effects of such recycling system.
The worlds need for sustainability in the fashion industry
According to fashion and textile professor, Debbie Moorhouse, the fashion industry is one of the most damaging industries when it comes to the environment: “Fashion is widely considered the second most destructive industry after oil, to the environment”. (Moorhouse, 2017, s. 1948). Seen in a historical context, sustainable fashion already emerged in the 1960s due to consumers’ awareness of how the production of clothing had an impact on the environment and demanded that the industry changed the way clothing was produced. This led to a sustainable fashion/slow fashion movement that “developed over the past decades” (Henninger, Alevizou, & Oates, 2016, s. 400) and focused on ideals such as sustainable values, reducing environmental damage et al.
In opposite to the sustainable fashion/slow fashion, “fast fashion” is described by author Tansy E. Hoskins in her book “Stitched Up: The Anti-Capitalist Book of Fashion” from 2014, as: “(…) a retail style that consists of the expedited production and distribution of short runs of trend-based fashion” (Hoskins, 2014, s. 70). This retail-style is used by many fashion brands such as ZARA, Nike, H&M, Primark et al. and the brands often produce their clothing in manufacturing fabrics located in both Bangladesh and China.The fast-fashion products “improve life quality, but meanwhile, they produce waste and pollution” (Zhi-Hua, Li, Chen, & Wang, 2014, s. 7063).
In April 2013 the Rana Plaza manufacturing fabric in Dhaka, Bangladesh collapsed during a workday. The collapse of the building caused the death of 1,133 workers and left 2,500 people with injuries. Many of the workers had, just a while before the collapse, argued with their managers about the building’s condition and their concerns about their safety while working in the fabric. As a result, the managers threatened the workers with a cut of their salary, for the entire month, which forced the workers to return to their work. The incident of Rana Plaza raised ethical and sustainable questions regarding fast fashion, production of clothing in the industry, as well as consumption of fashion, and “(…) fast fashion quickly becoming an undesirable model for consumers to support” (Hill, 2020).
Circular economy and fashion = circular fashion – what is that?
So what is my point in telling you about such a tragic incident? – let me explain…
The Rana Plaza incident increased, as mentioned above, ethical, and sustainable questions regarding production and consumption of fast fashion, and in 2014, the year after the incident, a new sustainable approach to consuming and producing fashion came to be. The new sustainable approach was introduced at a seminar held in Sweden, where: “a more circular approach to the fashion industry was the core focus” (Hill, 2020). Here fashion got combined with a circular economy business model which gave it its name – circular fashion. The circular economy is, in opposite to linear economy, a system that changes the way we use, dispose, and recycle objects and commodities. In the linear system, objects are made, used, and later disposed of which means, that raw materials used in the production of a product get disposed of instead of being recycled, which results in pollution. The circular system focuses on how objects/products get designed, produced, used, and reused to reduce pollution, minimize waste, and use less materials. This way, the materials get circulated in a larger recycling system and gets to be used in the production of a new product. You can see an example of the linear and the circular economy in the picture below.
Figure 1: Example of linear, (recycling) and circular economy
Circos – a brand based on circular fashion
So to give you an example of a brand that uses circular fashion, I present you with Circos. Circos is an online shop that provides, members of their rental subscription service, with maternity and children clothing. The Dutch company operates in 19 European countries and Circos aim to: “increase the use and prolong the life of garments that are typically used for only a short time” (Circos, n.d). By paying 19,50 EUR per month, the member can select and rent clothing from their online shop. The clothing items will be delivered in plant-based, compostable packages made from cornstarch, and the company’s shipping operation “is environmentally efficient and responsible” (Circos, n.d). When their members wish to return the rental clothing items, Circosdoes the laundry and dry cleaning before the next rent. According to Circos, their products are worn by 8 to 10 families before a piece of clothes is worn out and reused to make new products. As a result, their members extend the lifetime of their clothing collections.
Figure 2: Circos’ operating / circular fashion system
Discussion – is the circular fashion system sustainable?
I have now introduced you to the sustainability term regarding fashion, slow- and fast-fashion, the difference between the linear and the circular economy and why the circular economy got combined with the fashion industry. But is circular fashion really that sustainable – and is there only pros in this recycle system? Let’s take a look…
On one side, it can be argued, that the tragic Rana Plaza incident, has layered the foundation to rethink, take serious action and experiment with more sustainable and ethical alternatives to producing fashion within the industry. In this case, the incident forced the fashion industry to rethink its production system and consumers to rethink their consumption of fast fashion. This change is obviously a positive thing, and the circular fashion system supports the 12th SDG goal: Responsible consumption and production, that, for example, strive to get industries, consumers, and companies to reuse and reduce their waste in order to reduce pollution and to preserve our natural resources. On the other side, it can also be argued that the circular fashion system also has its flaws when it comes to the sustainable effects. According to a Finnish study that examinates renting- and recycling fashion, shows that circular fashion/rental clothing has a negative impact on the environment. This is due to the heavy use of transportation which can also be reflected in the way Circos operates: as mentioned earlier, Circos distributes rental clothing to 19 different countries within Europe and even though they argue that their transportation is environmentally friendly, is it not described with data and facts on their website. Another critical issue is the reproduction of textile fibres from old worn-out pieces of clothing. The study also showed that cultivating and harvesting cotton in fields produce less pollution, than recycling cotton from worn-out pieces, but other materials such as nylon and polyester contain a great deal of oil and therefore have a heavy CO2 emission when produced from new. As a result of that, it can be better to recycle and reuse these materials from old clothing items.
Furthermore, as mentioned above, Circos takes care of the laundry and dry cleaning before the next rent. This can be seen as a less sustainable element, because this could require a lot of chemicals and water and therefore have a negative impact on the world’s climate and increase the number of allergic reactions on the members bodies.
Conclusion
So what can we then conclude - after we have seen both some pros and cons when it comes to circular fashion? Based on abovementioned it can be concluded that the circular fashion system is furthermost an innovative and more ethical approach towards producing and consuming clothing as well as a system that challenges the fashion industry’s manufacturing approaches. Furthermore, the circular fashion system has the right sustainable intentions that, on paper, support the 12th SDG goal and is set to deal with some critical issues when it comes to the environment, reduction of pollution and CO2 emission. In practice, as seen in Circos, the circular fashion system- and renting approach is not as sustainable as it was intended to be due to the use of chemicals, the heavy amount of transportation to supply members with their rental orders and the release of pollution when reproducing textile fibres from old worn-out pieces. The circular fashion system is although a steppingstone in the research for more sustainable fashion alternatives in the future.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Circos. (n.d). About Circos. Hentet October 2021 fra Circos: https://circos.co/about/
CSR. (22. July 2021). Modeindustrien: Cirkulære forretningsmodeller som leje og genanvendelse kan være mere CO2-tunge end at smide tøjet ud. Hentet October 2021 fra CSR: https://csr.dk/modeindustrien-cirkulære-forretningsmodeller-som-leje-og-genanvendelse-kan-være-mere-co2-tunge-end
Henninger, C., Alevizou, P. J., & Oates, C. J. (6. July 2016). What is sustainable fashion? Journal of Fashion Marketing and Management. Hentet October 2021 fra Emerald Insight: https://www-emerald-com.proxy1-bib.sdu.dk/insight/content/doi/10.1108/JFMM-07-2015-0052/full/html
Hill, M. (06. July 2020). What is Circular Fashion? Hentet October 2021 fra Good on you: https://goodonyou.eco/what-is-circular-fashion/
Hoskins, T. E. (2014). Stitching It. I T. E. Hoskins, Stiched Up: The Anti-Capitalist Book of Fashion (s. 68-88). Pluto Press.
Moorhouse, D. (12-14. April 2017). Sustainable Design: Circular Economy in Fashion and Textiles. Hentet October 2021 fra Tandfonline: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/14606925.2017.1352713
Verdensmålene. (n.d). HVAD ER FN’S VERDENSMÅL FOR BÆREDYGTIG UDVIKLING? Hentet October 2021 fra FN's Verdensmål: https://www.verdensmaalene.dk/fakta/verdensmaalene
Zhi-Hua, H., Li, Q., Chen, X.-J., & Wang, Y.-F. (16. October 2014). Sustainable Rent-Based Closed-Loop Supply Chain for Fashion Products. Hentet October 2021 fra Proquest: https://www.proquest.com/docview/1624896712?accountid=14211&pq-origsite=summon
FIGURE LIST
Figure 1: Photo of the linear, recycling, and circular economy example. Located 18-10-2021 at: https://goodonyou.eco/what-is-circular-fashion/
Figure 2: Photo of the circular fashion system at Circos. Located 18-10-2021 at: https://www.allsubscriptionboxes.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/circos-01-1024x576.jpg